Man found guilty of sexually assaulting girl in 1990s

COURTS

Treated victim to chips and ice-cream

A 72-year-old man has been found guilty of sexually assaulting a girl in Galway during the 1990s. Raymond Heffernan of 143 Bohermore Road, Galway City was found guilty of four counts of sexual assault following a two-day trial at Galway Circuit Criminal Court.

The retired hospital porter had denied sexually assaulting his wife’s niece, contrary to Section 2 of the Criminal Law Rape Amendment Act.

After deliberating for three hours and 20 minutes, a jury of seven men and five women returned a unanimous guilty verdict on one count of sexual assault and a majority guilty verdict on three counts of sexual assault.

The victim, Aisling McGrath, of Knocknacarra, Galway – who waived her right to anonymity – was aged between seven and 12 when the offences occurred.

Ms McGrath, now 41, had alleged that Heffernan sexually assaulted her in public places while he treated her to chips and ice-cream during outings to Galway City and Salthill. The jury found Heffernan guilty of sexual assault on a date unknown between January 1, 1993, and December 31, 1993, outside Supermac’s in Eyre Square.

He was found guilty of sexual assault on dates unknown between January 1, 1993, and April 10, 1998, at Eddie Rocket’s, Eglington Street, Galway.

Unanimous verdit

Heffernan was found guilty of sexual assault on dates unknown between January 1, 1993, to April 10, 1998, at Seapoint amusement arcade, in Salthill. The jury also returned a unanimous guilty verdict in respect of a sexual assault by Heffernan at Eddie Rocket’s on Eglington Street on dates unknown between January 1, 1993, to April 10, 1998.

During this incident Ms McGrath said she felt “terrified” as his hand rubbed underneath her clothes as they sat together in the diner. “I just wanted it to stop but I didn’t say ‘stop’, I didn’t say anything,” she said.

During both Eddie Rocket’s incidents, she recalled Heffernan saying to her, “eat that up”, “good girl” and “are you enjoying that?”, while he touched her indecently.

Ms McGrath told prosecuting barrister Shane O’Callaghan that she froze and would “pretend it’s not happening and hope it would stop”.

She confided in her aunt Jennifer Banks in April 1998 when she was 12 and made a formal complaint to gardaí two years ago.

Ms Banks gave evidence that she in turn told her sister about the allegations, but it was agreed at the time, not to go to gardaí as this would have upset their father, Ms McGrath’s grandfather, who is now deceased.

Under cross examination the victim agreed with defence barrister Aisling Wall that it would be “extremely risky” of Heffernan to touch a child inappropriately in full view outside Supermac’s. Ms McGrath said the public nature of the assault made her even more frightened.

Memories 'haunted me'

Ms McGrath disclosed during the trial that she had suffered violence, including sexual abuse, as a child, from a different male perpetrator but she denied having “mixed up” memories. She said some memories were “vague” and “a blur”, but these memories were “not new” and “haunted me”.

Asked about the delay in making a formal complaint, Ms McGrath said she was in therapy, and it was “becoming unbearable to not deal with it”.

Heffernan, who did not take the stand, repeatedly denied all allegations during a cautioned interview with Detective Garda Karen Treacy in August 2024. “I did nothing, my conscience is clear,” he said in that interview. When asked about a motive for the complaints, he told Det Treacy, “that’s a consultant psychiatric job to see what’s going on in her head”.

Judge Brian O’Callaghan said Ms McGrath was no longer a complainant or alleged victim; she was a victim and could say to anyone who ever doubted her: “It’s true”.

He ordered a probation report on first-time offender Heffernan, who is under palliative care for gallbladder cancer.

Judge O’Callaghan acceded to a request by the victim to waive her anonymity and adjourned sentencing to next July to allow time for a probation report and victim impact statement.

Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme.